Author's Guide

This guide sets out the criteria for each type of submission to IJSaP, our style and formatting requirements, how to submit, and what happens after acceptance. You can also download the guide as a PDF. For a short overview and the links to start a submission, see the Submissions page.

Jump to a section

Should I Submit to IJSaP?

IJSaP is a developmental journal, and every submission goes through a desk review before anything else. "Not yet ready for review" is a common first decision. We send a manuscript to peer review only when we think it meets our criteria and has a real chance of acceptance after revision. Answering the questions below before you submit is the quickest way to avoid having your manuscript returned without review.

Q1. Is your article about the process of students working in partnership on learning and teaching in higher education, with other students, staff, and/or faculty?

This is the threshold question. We want to know how you worked in partnership, not only that you did something in partnership. If your article does not address this, IJSaP is not the right journal for it.

Q2. Have you submitted a proposal for this genre and received feedback from the editors?

We strongly encourage this. A proposal lets us give you feedback before you spend time writing (see section 2).

Q3. Which genre are you submitting under, and is your manuscript within the word limit for that genre (excluding the abstract, keywords, author biographies, and references, and including any endnotes, tables, and figures)?

We allow up to 5% over the limit. Submissions beyond that will be returned without review (see section 3).

Q4. Does your article meet the general criteria and the criteria for that genre?

See section 3.

Q5. If you are submitting a research article or case study, has it been anonymized?

Anonymizing means removing your name, institutional affiliation, and any other identifying information from the manuscript and from the file properties (see section 5).

Q6. If your research involved human participants, do you have institutional ethics approval?

Include a short statement at the end of the main text, before any acknowledgements, notes, or references. Give the name of the approving committee, the reference number if there is one, and the date of approval (see section 16). In the anonymized version, replace the institution's name with [Institution].

Q7. Does your manuscript follow the IJSaP formatting guidelines?

See section 5.

Q8. Do your citations and references follow APA 7 and IJSaP house style?

See sections 6 and 7.

If you cannot answer yes to Q1, please do not submit. If you are unsure about Q2 to Q8, the section referred to will tell you what to do.

Back to top

About This Guide

This guide brings together the criteria for each type of submission to the International Journal for Students as Partners (IJSaP), the journal's style and formatting requirements, instructions for submitting, and checklists for before submission and after acceptance.

The guide has three parts. Part I covers what you need to know before you submit. Part II covers what happens after your manuscript is accepted, including how to prepare it for copyediting. Part III sets out journal policies you may need to check less often.

If you are submitting for the first time, start with Should I Submit to IJSaP? above, then read Part I before you begin writing. Work through the checklist in section 9 before you submit.

For style and formatting questions not covered here, consult the APA Style website, which gives free guidance based on the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association (7th ed.). If you are unsure about anything, contact us at ijsap@mcmaster.ca.

Back to top

About the Journal

The International Journal for Students as Partners is a multidisciplinary, English-language journal about how students and staff (including academic staff/faculty, professional staff, and other stakeholders) work in partnership to enhance learning and teaching in higher education. It publishes new perspectives, practices, and policies for a wide readership across higher education, and we welcome disciplinary and interdisciplinary approaches to research.

The journal is run by its community, on the principle that students and staff working in partnership can transform higher education. Each editorial team is made up of a student (sometimes two) and a staff member who work as equal partners, and the teams come from institutions around the world. Our editors and reviewers see their role as helping authors develop their work, not as gatekeeping.

IJSaP is volunteer-run, hosted by McMaster University, and fully open access, with no fees for authors or readers. Since January 2026, we have published articles monthly as they become ready, on a rolling schedule. There may be several months between an article being sent for copyediting and its publication, because we balance the workloads of our copyeditor and editorial manager.

PART I: PREPARING TO SUBMIT

Back to top

1. Submit Your Best, Most Complete Work

Submissions to IJSaP have grown steadily, and our editorial teams, reviewers, and copyeditor are working at capacity. Please submit only work that is ready: the best and most complete version of the article you can produce, meeting all the criteria in this guide. Do not submit draft work in the hope of getting developmental feedback through review. If you would like feedback before you write, send us a proposal (see section 2).

Editorial teams apply the same desk review to every submission (see section 4). Submissions that are outside the journal's scope, more than 5% over the word limit, not anonymized where required, or missing a required ethics statement will be returned without review. Minor formatting and citation problems are not grounds for a return, and editors will ask you to correct them later. Submissions with seriously incomplete formatting or references may be returned. A return is not a rejection: we will tell you what needs to change before the article is ready for review.

Back to top

2. Proposals

If you have an idea for a contribution, we strongly encourage you to send the editors a short proposal before you write and submit the article. Use the questions in the proposal proforma for your genre: research article (including empirical research articles, theoretical or conceptual articles, and literature reviews), case study, opinion piece, reflective essay, or review or participant review. Email the proposal to ijsap@mcmaster.ca with the subject line "Proposal: [type of submission]", for example, "Proposal: Research Article". If the question format does not suit your proposal, you can send an abstract or summary that covers the same points as the proforma.

Before you send a proposal, check the general and genre-specific criteria in section 3 to confirm that your idea fits the genre you have chosen. A proposal saves time for you, the editors, and reviewers. With the number of submissions we now receive, it is also the best way to find out early whether your idea suits this genre in IJSaP.

We are open to proposals for other genres (for example, research posters, interviews, or conversations among participants in partnership dialogues) and other formats (for example, podcasts, videos, and animations). For these, send us an outline of the genre, the focus of your planned submission, and how it meets the general review criteria.

The free, open-access book Writing About Learning and Teaching in Higher Education: Creating and Contributing to Public Scholarly Conversations Across a Range of Genres (Healey, Matthews, & Cook-Sather, 2020) gives guidance on each IJSaP submission type, with chapters on research articles (12–14), case studies (15), reflective essays (18), opinion pieces (19), and preparing for submission (27). Chapters 9 (selecting a title), 10 (preparing the abstract), and 11 (extending the conventional writing genres) are useful when you prepare a proposal.

For research articles and case studies, you can search for further literature in Healey's (2026) selected bibliography on students as partners and change agents, which has about 2,000 references and is updated monthly.

Back to top

3. Types of Submissions

Genre Word limit Abstract and keywords Review process
Research articles 4,000 to 6,000 150-word abstract, up to 5 keywords Double-anonymous peer review
Case studies Up to 3,000 150-word abstract, up to 5 keywords Double-anonymous peer review
Opinion pieces Up to 900 None Peer review (non-anonymized)
Reflective essays Up to 3,000 None Dialogic review (non-anonymized)
Reviews Up to 800 None Peer review (non-anonymized)
Participant reviews No fixed limit, agreed with editors None Peer review (non-anonymized)

Word limits exclude the abstract, keywords, author biographies, and references, and include any endnotes and the words in tables and figures (see What counts toward the word limit, below). Appendices are no longer accepted (see section 5).

Criteria for all contributions

All contributions, whatever their type, must meet these criteria:

  • Be relevant to students as partners and explicitly discuss the implications of the work for partnership. The submission must analyze the partnership itself, not only describe a project in which students were involved.
  • Be a high-quality submission that addresses the interests of the journal's readers.
  • Meet the formatting guidelines in sections 5 to 7 of this guide.
  • Be clear, concise, complete, well written, and accessible to an international readership.
  • Not have been published before, and not be under consideration by another journal.

Editors also look for the following points, which often come up in feedback on proposals:

  • A clear explanation of what students as partners means in your context.
  • Enough detail about your institutional and cultural context for international readers.
  • Evidence for your claims and the lessons you draw.
  • A clear statement of what your work contributes to the literature on students as partners.

Reading published IJSaP articles in your genre is a good way to see what we look for.

Submissions that meet these criteria are then reviewed against the criteria for their type, set out below. Word limits are enforced at the desk stage (see section 4).

Research articles (4,000 to 6,000 words, plus 150-word abstract)

This category includes empirical research articles, conceptual and theoretical articles, and literature reviews. Each contributes new knowledge and understanding and uses a clear, appropriate methodology.

Criteria for review:

  • Presents original ideas or results supported by evidence, argument, and theory.
  • Reports ethically conducted research using appropriate methodologies.
  • Explains and justifies the methodology, with reference to appropriate literature.
  • Engages with the existing literature through relevant citations.
  • Critically analyzes impacts on students, staff, practice, and policy, as appropriate.

Case studies (up to 3,000 words, plus 150-word abstract)

Case studies are short scholarly explorations of specific practices, examples, or initiatives, including continuing and one-off projects, at any scale from a local practice to a national or global initiative. A case study explains the context and rationale for the work, situates it in the relevant literature, analyzes how the practice or initiative was implemented, identifies its strengths and weaknesses, and critically analyzes its impacts on students, staff, practice, and policy, as appropriate. We do not accept purely descriptive case studies.

Criteria for review:

  • Analyzes the implementation of an initiative.
  • Places the initiative in context by citing relevant literature.
  • Identifies the initiative's strengths and weaknesses.
  • Critically analyzes impacts on students, staff, practice, and policy, as appropriate.

Opinion pieces (up to 900 words)

Opinion pieces are short, thought-provoking pieces that take a position and support it with a persuasive argument. In exceptional cases they may be longer.

Criteria for review:

  • Addresses a current issue or debate about partnership in learning and teaching.
  • Puts forward innovative, provocative, and/or critical ideas about partnership.
  • Supports the argument with literature, lived experience, and/or evidence.

Reflective essays (up to 3,000 words)

Reflective essays are less formal, less polished pieces about the lived experience of partnership, including surprises, insights, questions, uncertainties, and other in-process aspects. We welcome individual essays of up to 3,000 words and sets of themed or institution-specific essays (normally no more than three).

Criteria for review:

  • Is an informal, first-person account of the lived experience of partnership.
  • Analyzes that experience, shedding light on the day-to-day practicalities of pedagogical partnership and/or the potential of such collaboration in higher education.
  • May include a small number of citations to existing literature.

Reflective essays go through our dialogic review process (see section 4). For further guidance, see this sample feedback on a reflective essay submission.

Reviews (up to 800 words)

Reviews cover books, conferences, symposia, or resources relevant to students as partners. Standard reviews (up to 800 words) engage critically with a single book, event, or resource. Participant reviews gather several voices on a specific event (see below).

Criteria for review (standard and participant reviews):

  • Describes briefly what the book, event, or resource is about, how it is structured, its key aims, messages, and conclusions, and who wrote or organized it.
  • Evaluates the significance of the work reviewed for students as partners in an international context.
  • Situates the work in relevant literature, discourse, or personal reflection on partnership.
  • Considers what the work means for partnership more broadly and, where appropriate, raises questions or ideas for future research or development.

Participant reviews (no fixed word limit)

A participant review is a collective reflection on an event. It brings together short reflections from people who took part in the event, instead of one reviewer's view. Participant reviews have no fixed word limit and are not solicited through open calls. They come from events where organizers or attendees want to record the shared experience for the partnership community.

A coordinating author organizes the review, compiles the contributions, and works with the editors to decide the scope, structure, and length that suit the event. If you are planning an event and think a participant review may fit, contact the editors at ijsap@mcmaster.ca before the event. This replaces the standard proposal process for this genre and means the review can be planned before contributors start writing. Participant reviews are submitted in the Reviews section of the journal system and are assessed against the same criteria as standard reviews.

What counts toward the word limit

The abstract (required for research articles and case studies only), keywords, author biographies, and reference list are not counted. Any endnotes and the words in tables and figures, including titles and captions, are counted. We allow up to 5% over the limit for each genre, both when you submit and when you upload your final manuscript for copyediting. State the word count at the end of your manuscript.

Back to top

4. How Your Submission Is Reviewed

Desk review

Every submission first goes through a desk review by the editorial team. The desk review checks that the submission is about students-as-partners practice, is within the word limit, is fully anonymized (for research articles and case studies), is correctly formatted, and meets the basic quality threshold for its genre. Editors across the journal apply the same checks, using the checklist in section 9.

We want your work to have the best chance of a positive outcome. If it is not suitable for the journal, we want to tell you quickly so that you can find another outlet. There are three possible outcomes for your submission:

  1. It is sent directly to peer review.
  2. It is returned with a request for specific revisions before review, and you are invited to resubmit under the same submission number once you have made them.
  3. It is declined, because the work is clearly outside IJSaP's scope or does not meet our quality standards. We explain the reasons for a decline and, where possible, suggest other journals.

Submissions more than 5% over the word limit for their section will be returned at the desk stage, with an invitation to shorten and resubmit.

Peer review

Research articles and case studies go through double-anonymous review by student and staff reviewers from our International Reviewer Panel. Opinion pieces and reviews are peer reviewed without anonymization. Our reviewers give developmental feedback. They read as knowledgeable colleagues who want to help you reach your goals for the work, while holding it to the standards we set for everything we publish.

All our editors and reviewers are volunteers who do this work alongside their other roles, and finding reviewers can take time. It is not unusual for the process from submission to decision to take up to six months.

We can respond more quickly when manuscripts meet the journal's formatting and style requirements, include complete and accurate references, and follow the submission steps in section 8.

Dialogic review for reflective essays

Reflective essays receive a non-anonymized dialogic review, in which editors, authors, and reviewers work together in a shared Google Doc. The editors create the Doc and give editing access to the reviewers and authors. Once reviewers have been recruited, the review takes place through dialogue, usually over 8 to 10 weeks. This approach gives space to people's emotions and experiences, which makes the review more supportive and developmental.

The editors invite a faculty or staff reviewer and a student reviewer, introduce them to the authors, and send a tentative timeline and the link to the Google Doc. Authors and reviewers then work through successive rounds, with the editors overseeing the process. When the authors have responded to the reviewers' feedback, the editors give their responses and make the final decision. If you would prefer an anonymized review, tell us in the Comments for the Editor field when you submit your essay.

Decisions after review

After peer review, the editorial team makes one of four decisions:

  1. Accept. The manuscript moves to copyediting (see Part II).
  2. Minor changes. You make the requested changes, usually within 4 weeks, and the editors check them.
  3. Major changes (revise and resubmit). You revise the manuscript, usually within 8 weeks, and it may go back to reviewers.
  4. Decline. The manuscript will not be published in IJSaP. We explain the reasons.

Revised manuscripts must stay within 5% of the word limit for their genre. Revisions often add words, so check the count before you upload a revised version. You will receive instructions through the journal system. If special circumstances mean that you need extra time, contact the editorial team that sent you the decision.

After a major changes (revise and resubmit) decision, you will normally have one opportunity to revise. If the revised submission still does not meet the required standard, it will be declined rather than sent through further rounds. The decision email will remind you of this. We explain these decisions developmentally. If you have questions about the revisions you have been asked to make, contact the editorial team that sent you the decision, so that you are in the best position to respond to the reviews.

Back to top

5. Preparing Your Manuscript

IJSaP follows APA style in most respects, with some exceptions for formatting and capitalization. Please look closely at the Sample Formatted Manuscript in section 12. Submissions must be in English (Australian, UK, Canadian, or US English, used consistently throughout). Use one of these dictionaries for spelling and usage: Merriam-Webster for US English, the Canadian Oxford Dictionary for Canadian English, the Oxford English Dictionary for British English, or the Macquarie Dictionary for Australian English.

Structure

  • Every manuscript should include a title, the article body, endnotes (if needed), and references. Please do not use footnotes.
  • Research articles and case studies must also include an abstract of up to 150 words and up to five keywords. Do not include an abstract with other types of submission.
  • For research articles and case studies, do not include author bylines, affiliations, or a note on contributors in your initial submission. These are added after acceptance (see section 11).
  • We recommend using headings to help readers find their way through the text, unless your manuscript is shorter than two pages.
  • The introduction does not have a heading. APA style treats the manuscript title as the heading for the introduction, so any headings within that first section start at level 2. The heading levels IJSaP uses are shown under General formatting below. For heading structures beyond these, see the APA Style guidance on headings.
  • If your submission reports research involving human participants, include a statement confirming institutional ethics approval at the end of the main text, before any acknowledgements, notes, or references. Give the name of the committee, the reference number if there is one, and the date of approval (see section 16 for an example).
  • Acknowledgements are optional and are added after acceptance.

Appendices

IJSaP no longer publishes appendices. If you think supplementary material is necessary, deposit it in a repository that gives it a DOI or other persistent identifier (for example, an institutional repository, OSF, or Zenodo), and link to it in the text. Supplementary material should not be used to extend the word limit. Material published in the article carries the journal's editorial approval, which we cannot extend to supplementary files.

General formatting

  • All margins must be 1 inch (2.54 cm).
  • Use 12-point Calibri for all text, except the manuscript title, which is 16-point Calibri, bold.
  • Align text to the left and use single spacing, with no extra space between paragraphs.
  • Indent the first line of each paragraph by 0.5 inches, except the first paragraph of a section.
  • Level 1 headings are in capital letters, flush left. Level 2 headings are bold, with only the first word capitalized. Level 3 headings are italic, with only the first word capitalized. Do not indent headings. The three levels look like this:

LEVEL 1 HEADINGS IN CAPITAL LETTERS, FLUSH LEFT

Level 2 headings in bold, only the first word capitalized

Level 3 headings in italics, only the first word capitalized

Figures and tables

  • Place figures and tables where they should appear in the published article, not at the end of the manuscript or in a separate file.
  • Mention or discuss each one in the text, and number them in the order they are mentioned.
  • Give each one a brief descriptive title.
  • To meet accessibility standards, each figure must include alternative text (alt text). A screen reader reads alt text aloud, so it lets people who cannot see a figure understand what it shows and why it matters. Alt text should briefly describe the figure's content and purpose.

Appropriate: Figure showing the stages of adaptive learning: encounter, inquiry, experimentation, and adoption.

Not appropriate: Figure of the adaptive learning model.

  • If a figure is too complex to describe in alt text, explain it more fully in the text where you refer to it, and say so in the alt text (for example, "Figure showing the cyclical nature of the model, which is discussed in detail in the text."). To add alt text in Microsoft Word, right-click the image, select Edit Alt Text, and type one or two short sentences.
  • Do not use colour alone to convey meaning in figures. Each figure should make sense when converted to greyscale.
  • Give tables logical row and column headers, with the first row clearly identifying the information listed below it. Screen readers use these headers to help users understand a table. Do not use tables for layout, for example, to set two blocks of text side by side or to line up a list of names and roles. Use paragraphs, lists, or headings instead.

Anonymizing your submission

Anonymization requirements depend on the type of submission. Research articles and case studies go through double-anonymous review, so the submitted version must be fully anonymized. Reflective essays go through the non-anonymized dialogic review described in section 4 and should be submitted with author names, unless you ask for an anonymized review when you submit. Opinion pieces, reviews, and participant reviews should not be anonymized.

For research articles and case studies, remove the authors' names and institutional affiliations from the manuscript. Do not include cover pages, biographies, acknowledgements, or anything else that could identify you. Identifying information can be added if the manuscript is accepted.

  • When citing your own work, use "Author (2018)" in the text. In the reference list, replace the full reference with "Author (2018). Details omitted for double-anonymous reviewing." and list these entries alphabetically under A. Replace phrases such as "as we have shown in our previous study" with the third person, for example, "as shown before in Author (2018)."
  • Remove any identifying information from your Word file's properties. To do this, open the document, click File, scroll down to Properties, and delete any identifying information.
  • Enter author details in the journal system, not in the manuscript. Include all authors' names and affiliations and the corresponding author's contact information, including a phone number and email address. Author details are used by journal administrators and are not shown to reviewers.

Back to top

6. House Style

Capitalization

  • Capitalize only the first word of the article title and subtitle, and proper nouns.
  • There is debate about whether "students as partners" names the field or the method that is the focus of this journal (Cook-Sather, Matthews, Ntem, et al., 2018), so we invite authors to follow their own convictions in choosing uppercase or lowercase for this term. We welcome this diversity because we aim to make our publishing equitable and inclusive. If you are unsure, or your use is inconsistent, our default is lowercase ("students as partners").

Example: More and more faculty are working with students as partners.

Example: The students-as-partners literature base is growing.

Example: As a framework for theory and practice, Students as Partners is gaining traction.

  • Do not capitalize academic fields and disciplines unless they are proper nouns (for example, students studied sociology and English).
  • Do not capitalize course assignments, theories, concepts, hypotheses, models, or methodologies unless they include a proper noun (for example, Likert-type).
  • Capitalize official course titles (Students registered in Research Methods had the option to participate). Use lowercase for a general type of course (first-year communications courses are challenging to design).
  • Capitalize a job title or position when it comes before a name (Professor Nguyen), but not otherwise (Sandra Nguyen is a professor of sociology).
  • When you mention the title of a work in your text, use title case: capitalize all words of four letters or more. Do not capitalize "of" or "and" (Journal of Higher Education Theory and Practice).

Italics

  • Italicize the titles of books, reports, journals, and other stand-alone works, including this journal's name (IJSaP). In the reference list, italicize the journal name and volume number.
  • You may italicize a key term the first time you use it. After that, set it in regular type.
  • Italicize statistical symbols and variables (for example, M, SD, p).
  • Do not use italics for emphasis, or for quotations from research participants.

Abbreviations

  • Spell out each abbreviation in full the first time it appears in the manuscript, followed by the abbreviation in parentheses. Use these forms for common abbreviations: IJSaP (International Journal for Students as Partners), SaP (Students as Partners), SoTL (scholarship of teaching and learning), MA, PhD, CD, HTML, APA, US, USA, UK.

Punctuation

  • Use the serial comma (often called the Oxford comma) before "and": students attend lectures, tutorials, and a weekly lab.
  • Use one space after punctuation such as periods or question marks, not two. If your manuscript has two or more spaces after punctuation, use Word's Find and Replace function to replace them with a single space.
  • Do not use quotation marks to highlight a key term (use italics for its first mention instead, see Italics above) or to hedge or downplay meaning.
  • Use double quotation marks. Use single quotation marks only for a quotation within a quotation.
  • Do not put spaces before or after dashes. Use an en dash (–) for ranges of numbers, pages, and dates (pp. 12–18, 2019–2021). Use an em dash (—) to set off an interruption in a sentence (the partners—two students and a lecturer—met weekly). To type these in Word, use Insert > Symbol > Special Characters. On a Mac, press Option+Hyphen for an en dash and Option+Shift+Hyphen for an em dash.
  • Hyphenate a compound term when it comes before the word it modifies. Do not hyphenate it when it is used as a noun or comes after the word it modifies. For example: problem-solving skills are key to student development, but problem solving is key to student development.

Style

  • Contractions (such as don't, it's, and we're) are acceptable in opinion pieces, reflective essays, and reviews. Avoid them in research articles and case studies.
  • Use the active voice where you can: "they conducted an action-research study" rather than "an action-research study was conducted."
  • Use respectful, non-discriminatory, and inclusive language. Use person-first or identity-first language as appropriate for the community you are discussing, use the terms individuals and communities use for themselves, and avoid stigmatizing or stereotyping language. See the Human Research Ethics Policy in the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies and the APA guidelines on bias-free language.

Back to top

7. Citations and References (APA 7)

Follow APA style (7th edition) for references and in-text citations. The APA Style website has free guidance on both.

In-text citations and quotations

  • Give a page number for every direct quotation, for example, (Bains, 2019, p. 16) or (Bains, 2019, pp. 16–17). For sources without page numbers, give a paragraph number (para. 4) or a section heading instead.
  • Format quotations of 40 words or more as block quotations. Indent the whole quotation 0.5 inches from the left margin, leave a blank line before and after it, single-space it, and do not use quotation marks. In a block quotation, the final punctuation comes at the end of the quoted text, and the parenthetical citation follows with no punctuation after it.
  • Do not let a quotation stand alone. Introduce every quotation in your own words and integrate it into your text.
  • Place periods and commas inside closing quotation marks. When a parenthetical citation follows the quotation, the period goes after the citation instead. Question marks go inside the quotation marks only when they are part of the original quotation.

Example: One participant commented that "the assignment was too easy," while another reported that it "was too challenging if you didn't have previous experience."

Example: Bains (2019) argues that "it's imperative that learning be scaffolded" (p. 16).

  • Use an ellipsis to show that you have left out words within a quotation. You do not need an ellipsis at the beginning or end of a quotation. To shorten a sentence, type three periods separated by spaces, followed by any punctuation needed. To join two sentences, end the first sentence with a period, add a space, then type three spaced periods.

Example: One participant responded, "I couldn't believe . . . how helpful the process was."

  • Use square brackets for additions or explanations you have inserted into a quotation.

Example: One participant said, "I did not expect [the lecturer] to ask for our views on the assessment."

  • When quoting research participants, use the same formatting and punctuation as for other quotations, without special formatting such as italics. Do not include participants in your reference list. State in the text that the quotations are from participants.
  • Cite secondary sources sparingly, for example, when the original is out of print or not available in a language you read. Name the original work in your text and cite the source you read, for example: Allport's diary (as cited in Nicholson, 2003). List only the source you read in the reference list. See the APA Style guidance on secondary sources.

Reference list

  • Format each entry with a hanging indent of 0.5 inches, with a space between entries.
  • Arrange references alphabetically by the first author's surname. Order multiple works by the same author by year of publication, earliest first.
  • When you cite more than one work by the same author(s) from the same year, add lowercase letters after the year (2020a, 2020b). Assign the letters in alphabetical order of the titles in the reference list, and use the same letters in your in-text citations.
  • For a work with up to 20 authors, include all the authors' names. For a work with 21 or more authors, include the first 19 names, an ellipsis, and the final name.
  • Publication location is no longer required in APA style.
  • Include DOIs whenever possible, in this format: https://doi.org/xxxx
  • Give URLs for references when they are available. APA no longer requires URLs to be preceded by "Retrieved from."
  • Omit page numbers for journal articles if the journal is online and does not give page numbers.
  • Spell out acronyms in the reference list, followed by the acronym in parentheses, for example: Higher Education Academy (HEA). (2016).

Reference examples

See the APA Style Common Reference Examples guide for how to cite journal articles, books, edited book chapters, webpages, reports, and unpublished or forthcoming work.

Back to top

8. How to Submit

  1. Check your manuscript against the criteria and the checklist. Confirm your submission type, its word limit, and the review criteria in section 3, then work through the checklist in section 9.
  2. Prepare your Comments for the Editor. Use the Comments for the Editor field only for information the editors need that is not in the manuscript. For example, tell us if you sent a proposal for this submission (with the date and the feedback you received), if you are requesting an anonymized review for a reflective essay, or if there is anything unusual about the submission. Keep the comments brief, and do not use the field for the abstract, a cover letter, or anything that belongs in the manuscript. The editorial team assesses your submission from the manuscript itself, so make sure the abstract and introduction show clearly what your work contributes to the students-as-partners field.
  3. Save your manuscript as a single Word or OpenOffice file. Save the manuscript as a single Word (.doc or .docx) or OpenOffice file. Please do not submit PDFs. If you want to submit audio or visual files, email the editorial team at ijsap@mcmaster.ca.
  4. Create an account. To submit an article, you first need an account at https://mulpress.mcmaster.ca/ijsap/user/register, with the Author box ticked. The account lets you upload your submission and follow its progress through review to publication. If you already have an account, log in with your existing details. If you do not see an author section on your user home page, click Edit My Profile and tick the Author box under Roles. You are encouraged, but not required, to connect your ORCID iD to your profile.
  5. Check your email settings. Before you start, make sure your email account accepts messages from ijsap@mcmaster.ca, because notification emails may go to spam or junk folders.
  6. Upload and complete the submission form. Select the journal section that matches your submission type. Complete the metadata, including all authors' names and affiliations and the corresponding author's phone number and email address. Add any Comments for the Editor (see step 2), tick the items on the Submission Preparation Checklist, and upload your manuscript, anonymized where required (see section 5).

IJSaP does not require a separate cover letter. The declarations a cover letter would usually make (that the manuscript is submitted only to IJSaP and presents new, unpublished findings or arguments) are made through the Submission Preparation Checklist.

After you submit, you will receive updates on your submission through the journal system, with automatic email notifications. Contributions may be submitted at any time. Accepted articles are published on the journal's rolling schedule as they become ready.

Start a new submission in the section for your genre: Research Articles, Case Studies, Opinion Pieces, Reflective Essays, or Reviews (including participant reviews).

Back to top

9. Submission Preparation Checklist

Before submitting, confirm each of the following. If items are missing or incomplete, your submission may be returned as not yet ready to go out for peer review.

  1. The submission is explicitly about partnership between students and staff, analyzes the partnership itself, and discusses the implications of the work for partnership. It is not simply an account of a project in which students were involved.
  2. I have read the general criteria and the criteria for my genre, and I believe the submission meets them.
  3. My email account is set to accept messages from ijsap@mcmaster.ca, as notification emails can go to spam or junk folders.
  4. The word count is stated at the end of the manuscript. It excludes the abstract (research articles and case studies only), keywords, author biographies, and references, and includes any endnotes and the words in tables and figures.
  5. The word count is no more than 5% over the maximum for the section of the journal I am submitting to. I understand that submissions beyond that will be returned without review.
  6. An abstract of up to 150 words and up to five keywords are included (research articles and case studies only).
  7. The manuscript has been anonymized as required for the submission type (research articles and case studies), following the guidance in section 5, including self-citations and Word file properties.
  8. The submission file is a single Microsoft Word (.doc or .docx) or OpenOffice document, not a PDF.
  9. The manuscript is submitted only to IJSaP and presents new, unpublished findings or arguments (including translated works).
  10. Where the contribution reports research involving human participants, a statement confirming institutional ethics approval (committee name, reference number if applicable, and approval date) is included at the end of the main text, before any acknowledgements, notes, or references (see section 16).
  11. The text is single-spaced, uses 12-point Calibri, and has 1-inch margins, and all illustrations, figures, and tables are placed within the text at the appropriate points, not at the end.
  12. References and in-text citations follow APA style (7th edition), including DOIs and URLs where available.
  13. The manuscript contains no appendices. Any supplementary material is deposited in a repository and linked through a URL.
  14. The submission complies with the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies. Any conflict of interest arising from the publication of this work has been disclosed, and everyone who contributed is acknowledged or listed as an author in line with the authorship requirements.
  15. Any use of generative AI beyond basic grammar and spell-checking has been disclosed in the manuscript, in line with the IJSaP Generative AI Policy.

PART II: AFTER ACCEPTANCE AND PREPARING FOR COPYEDITING

Back to top

10. What Happens After Acceptance

When your manuscript is accepted, you will receive a decision email with the reviewers' comments and editorial feedback. Check the manuscript carefully against the style guidelines and for any remaining typographical errors. Substantive revisions are not allowed at this stage.

The final manuscript must still be no more than 5% over the word limit for its genre. Prepare the manuscript for copyediting using sections 11 to 13, and upload it within 30 days of the acceptance decision (contact us if you need more time), and use the checklist in section 15 to confirm that everything is in place before you upload it. When we receive your updated manuscript, we send it to our copyeditor for final editing. You will have another chance to review the article before it is published.

Back to top

11. Formatting the Final Manuscript

Add the following elements after your manuscript has been accepted. Do not include them in the anonymized version you submit for review.

De-anonymizing the manuscript

Now that peer review is complete, restore the identifying information you removed for review:

  • Author names and affiliations in the document.
  • Any acknowledgements, funding statements, or details of ethics approval that identify you or your institution.
  • Any self-citations that were anonymized. Replace "Author (2018)" with the full citation in both the text and the reference list.
  • A short note on contributors, if not already included (see below).

Adding author bylines and affiliations

Add a byline for each author with their name and affiliation, and include a contact email address for the corresponding author. Mark the corresponding author with an asterisk before their first name. This email address will appear in the published article.

Note on contributors

Add a Note on Contributors section with a short biography for each author (no more than 50 words each, in italics). Focus on current information, such as position, teaching, and research interests, and say who was a student when the work or initiative was carried out.

Acknowledgements and funding

Acknowledgements are optional. If you want to thank someone who inspired your project, colleagues who gave feedback on your manuscript, or the office that funded it, add an Acknowledgements section after the main text. Make sure any funding is also listed in the manuscript metadata.

Conflict of interest statement

Add a conflict of interest statement after the acknowledgements, for example, "The authors declare no conflicts of interest." If the work was funded, you might write: "This research was funded by [organization]. The funder had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, or preparation of the manuscript." See section 16.

Back to top

12. Sample Formatted Manuscript

This sample shows the elements specific to the final, de-anonymized version of your manuscript, prepared after acceptance. For font, margins, headings, figures, and tables, see section 5. For quotations and citations, see section 7. The sample has no appendices section, because IJSaP no longer publishes appendices.

MANUSCRIPT TYPE (RESEARCH ARTICLE/CASE STUDY/OPINION PIECE/REFLECTIVE ESSAY/REVIEW)

Title

Firstname Lastname A and Firstname Lastname B, Department AB, Institution AB, Country AB. Please indicate the corresponding author by adding an asterisk before the first name.

Firstname Lastname C, Department C, Institution C, Country C.

Contact (for corresponding author only): email@address

ABSTRACT (research articles and case studies only)

Abstracts of up to 150 words should be indented 0.5 in. and single-spaced.

KEYWORDS (research articles and case studies only)

five lowercase keywords, each separated by commas, keyword

The body of your manuscript follows the heading, paragraph, figure, and table rules in section 5 and the quotation rules in section 7. The elements below are specific to this final, de-anonymized version.

If your submission reports research involving human participants, include a statement confirming institutional ethics approval here, at the end of the main text and before any acknowledgements, notes, or references. Give the committee name, the reference number if applicable, and the date of approval. Italicize the statement. If you include a data availability statement, place it after the ethics statement.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Acknowledgements are optional, but if you want to thank someone who inspired your project, colleagues who offered feedback on your manuscript, or the office that funded your project, please do so here. Make sure any funding is also listed in the manuscript metadata.

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

NOTES

1. This is the first note, corresponding to the superscript number 1 in the text. Use normal paragraph spacing.

NOTE ON CONTRIBUTORS

Firstname Lastname is/specializes in . . . Insert a biography of up to 50 words, in italics. Focus on current biographical information (position, teaching, and research interests). Indicate who was a student at the time the work was undertaken.

REFERENCES

Healey, M., Flint, A., & Harrington, K. (2014). Students as partners in learning and teaching in higher education. Higher Education Academy. https://www.advance-he.ac.uk/knowledge-hub/engagement-through-partnership-students-partners-learning-and-teaching-higher

Mercer-Mapstone, L. D., Dvorakova, S. L., Matthews, K. E., Abbot, S., Cheng, B., Felten, P., Knorr, K., Marquis, E., Shammas, R., & Swaim, K. (2017). A systematic literature review of Students as Partners in higher education. International Journal for Students as Partners, 1(1), 1–23. https://doi.org/10.15173/ijsap.v1i1.3119

Back to top

13. Submitting for Copyediting

Once your manuscript is fully prepared following sections 11 and 12, upload it within 30 days of the acceptance decision:

  1. Type FOR COPYEDIT at the top of the document.
  2. Rename your file using the format [submission number]_[your last name]_TC, for example, 1234_Smith_TC.docx. Your submission number appears next to your name in your submission queue. TC shows that this version is going to copyediting.
  3. Log in to the system at https://mulpress.mcmaster.ca/ijsap/user.
  4. Click on your active submission, and then on the article title.
  5. Make sure you are on the Review tab.
  6. Scroll down to the Revisions panel and click Upload File.
  7. Upload your revised and de-anonymized manuscript as a new file, not as a revision of an existing file.

Back to top

14. The Editorial Production Process

Once your manuscript is submitted for copyediting, it goes through four stages before publication:

  1. Copyediting. The copyeditor checks the manuscript for language, style, APA formatting, and house style, working directly in the file and leaving tracked changes and comments for you to address.
  2. Author review of copyediting. You review the copyedited file and respond to each comment. You do not need to act on tracked changes you agree with. This stage is a review of the copyeditor's work, not a chance to make new content revisions.
  3. Page proof. Once your response to copyediting is confirmed, we prepare a PDF page proof, a formatted version of the manuscript as it will appear in the journal. Check the proof carefully for any remaining errors. Only minor corrections are accepted at this stage, and no new content changes are permitted.
  4. Production lock. Once the page proof is approved, the manuscript is locked and scheduled for publication. No further changes of any kind are accepted after this point.

Completing your copyediting review

When your manuscript reaches the author review of copyediting stage, complete your review using these steps:

  1. Download the copyedited file from the Copyediting discussion thread in the submission system.
  2. Review all tracked changes in the document. If you agree with an edit, no action is needed. If you disagree, revise the text.
  3. Respond to all Author Queries in the document. If you agree with a suggested change and no revision is needed, click the thumbs-up icon on the comment to show you have seen it. If you decide not to follow a suggestion, reply to the query to say so.
  4. Upload your revised file to the same discussion thread, or email it to ijsap@mcmaster.ca.
  5. Post a brief message in the discussion thread confirming that your review is complete. This tells us the file is ready to collect and helps keep the production queue moving.

Please return your reviewed file within two weeks of receiving the copyedited manuscript. If you need more time or have questions, contact the editorial manager at ijsap@mcmaster.ca. You can also include questions for the editorial manager in your message when you upload the revised file.

Back to top

15. Post-Acceptance Checklist

Confirm each of the following before you upload your manuscript for copyediting.

  1. Any final corrections requested in the acceptance decision are complete. No substantive revisions have been made.
  2. The final manuscript is no more than 5% over the word limit for its genre (counting endnotes and the words in tables and figures).
  3. The manuscript has been checked against the style requirements in this guide and for any remaining typographical errors.
  4. Each figure includes alternative text and is legible in greyscale, and tables have descriptive column headers in the first row.
  5. The manuscript is labelled FOR COPYEDIT at the top.
  6. The manuscript has been de-anonymized, including restoring author names, affiliations, identifying acknowledgements or funding statements, and previously anonymized self-citations.
  7. Author bylines and affiliations have been added, with the corresponding author marked by an asterisk.
  8. A contact email address for the corresponding author is included.
  9. A Note on Contributors section has been added, with a biography of no more than 50 words for each author.
  10. A conflict of interest statement has been added after the acknowledgements.
  11. Acknowledgements and notes have been added, if applicable, and any funding is listed in the manuscript metadata.
  12. The file has been renamed in the format [submission number]_[last name]_TC.
  13. The file has been uploaded as a new file to the Revisions panel on the Review tab, within 30 days of the acceptance decision.

PART III: ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Back to top

16. Authorship, Ethics, and Journal Policies

IJSaP follows the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). This section sets out what authors need to do. For the full policies, see the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies.

Authorship

To qualify for authorship, a person must meet both of these criteria. First, they made a substantial contribution to the conception, design, execution, analysis, or interpretation of the work, or to drafting the manuscript or substantial sections of it. Second, they take accountability for the work and how it is presented. Everyone who meets these criteria should be listed as an author, and every listed author must meet them. Students who make substantial contributions should be recognized as authors, not only in the acknowledgements. Gift, ghost, guest, and coercive authorship all breach IJSaP's standards. If you are unsure whether someone meets the criteria, see the COPE authorship discussion document.

Discuss and agree on authorship and author order with all collaborators early in the project. Author order should reflect relative contribution, usually the contribution to writing the article, not institutional status. One author must be named as the corresponding author. After submission, changes to authorship must be requested in writing by the corresponding author and approved by all authors and the editors. After acceptance, changes are not permitted except in exceptional circumstances. With their permission, acknowledge contributors who do not meet the authorship criteria, such as people who provided technical help, resources, or editing. See the full Authorship and Contributorship Policy in the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies.

Research ethics: human participants

All research involving human participants must be reviewed and approved by the author's institutional research ethics committee or IRB before submission. Include an italicized statement at the end of the main text, before any acknowledgements, notes, or references. The statement should give the name of the committee, the reference number or approval code if applicable, and the date of approval:

Example: This research was reviewed and approved by the [Name of Institution] Research Ethics Board (Reference number: [XXX], approved [date]).

In the anonymized version submitted for review, replace the institution and committee names with [Institution]. If the research was exempt from review, state the reason for the exemption and the body that made the decision. Pay particular attention to power dynamics and voluntary consent when researching your own students or partners. Follow Indigenous research ethics frameworks, such as OCAP (Ownership, Control, Access, and Possession), where they apply. See the full Human Research Ethics Policy in the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies.

Conflicts of interest

You must disclose all potential conflicts of interest. These include financial conflicts (such as funding, employment, or honoraria related to the work) and non-financial conflicts (such as relationships or affiliations that could be seen as influencing the work). Declare conflicts at submission through the checklist. In the final version, include a conflict of interest statement after the acknowledgements, as described in section 11. Expertise or experience in students as partners is not a conflict. See the full Conflict of Interest Policy in the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies.

Generative AI

AI tools cannot be listed as authors. You remain fully responsible for the integrity, originality, and accuracy of all content, including checking any AI-generated material and every citation. You must disclose any AI use beyond basic grammar and spell-checking. Acceptable uses, with disclosure, include literature search and organization, language and writing assistance, data analysis support with verification, brainstorming, and technical assistance. Prohibited uses include generating manuscripts or substantial sections without significant human intellectual contribution, fabricating citations or data, and concealing AI's role in generating text, analysis, or interpretation. In reflective essays and other genres centred on personal voice, keep AI use beyond grammar checking to a minimum.

Disclose AI use in the methods section (for research articles and case studies) and/or in a disclosure statement before the references. Name the tool and version, the specific purposes, and the extent of its contribution, and confirm that the authors checked the output:

Example: Disclosure of AI use: This manuscript was drafted by the authors with assistance from [AI tool name] for [specific purpose]. All content was reviewed, verified, and substantially revised by the authors. [AI tool] was not used to generate arguments, interpretations, or conclusions.

Basic grammar and spell-checking, standard word-processing features, and reference-management software do not need to be disclosed. When in doubt, disclose. See the full Generative AI Policy in the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies.

Data availability

Submissions reporting empirical research may include a data availability statement, placed at the end of the main text, before any acknowledgements, notes, or references. If the manuscript also has a research ethics statement, the data availability statement follows it. The statement says whether the data underlying the findings are available, where and how they can be accessed, and any restrictions and the reasons for them. IJSaP puts ethics first: participant confidentiality and ethical commitments take precedence over data sharing.

Example: The qualitative data supporting this study's findings are not publicly available due to ethical restrictions related to participant confidentiality. Summary data and anonymized quotes are provided in the manuscript.

Sharing is encouraged for quantitative data that can be fully anonymized and for supporting materials such as survey instruments, interview guides, and coding schemes. Deposit them in a recognized repository, such as the Open Science Framework (OSF), the Qualitative Data Repository, Zenodo, or an institutional repository. Supporting materials cannot be published as appendices (see section 5). See the full Data Sharing and Reproducibility Policy in the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies.

You must obtain and document permission for any third-party content in your manuscript, including images, figures, or tables from other publications, and any long quotations that go beyond fair use. Instructions for obtaining permission are usually on the original publication's website, or you can contact the rights holder.

Corrections, complaints, and appeals

If you find an error in your published work, contact ijsap@mcmaster.ca promptly. Corrections address minor errors and retractions address serious problems, following COPE guidelines. You may appeal an editorial decision if you believe it was based on a misunderstanding, that important information was not considered, or that the process was not followed correctly. Appeals must present substantive new information or evidence, not only disagreement, and are reviewed by editors who were not involved in the original decision. Procedures and timelines are set out in the Complaints and Appeals Policy and the Corrections and Retractions Policy in the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies.

Back to top

Authors keep copyright and grant the journal the right of first publication, with the work licensed at the same time under a Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0). This allows others to share the work, provided they acknowledge its authorship and first publication in this journal.

IJSaP supports open scholarship and does not treat a preprint as prior publication. You may post preprints on preprint servers or in institutional repositories before submission. You may post accepted manuscripts (postprints) after publication, or after acceptance if you provide a link to the final published version once it is available. Posted versions should acknowledge first publication in IJSaP. For author rights and third-party content, see the Authorship and Contributorship Policy in the IJSaP Publication Ethics Policies.

The names and email addresses entered on the journal site will be used only for the stated purposes of this journal and will not be made available for any other purpose or to any other party.

Back to top